3 Comments
User's avatar
Eric B HOCHBERG's avatar

Let  me preface my remarks first by saying that at its inception, I, a tech guy for the past 50 years, was a big Holmes/Theranos fan. We WILL all have a desktop or smaller machine in the future that could provide these blood labs/assays. She might have done it had she brought on-board industry pros — from Siemens for example, whose machines she used that are the industry gold standard for this tech. But no, pumping the fake-it-until-you-make it kool aid to an audience thirsty for the next Steve Jobs - and a woman no less! — the story that should be rigorously psychologically documented is how she was able to snow so many.

Did you not see that oily snake slithering thru the movie?

Non-scientist, non psychologist, un-rigorous, faux “documentarian” Fielder trying to humanize rehabilitate or at least understand Holmes psyche - ends up looking only like arty profiteering — with some heavy leverage from A24 and Seyfried — on our undying fascination with the Holmes Svengali mystique - this while Holmes & Billy play Fielder to help him tell a sympathetic story that might keep the blood & oxygen flowing on the Holmes project /vision/delusion/scam

Perhaps the movie would have been better named: “There will be (more) blood.”

Enter your piece. Another one - a psychologist no less! - mesmerized by the Holmes gaze. “All good” this faux documentary? Oh please. Where were you subject matter expert at the trial to defend her on-the-spectrum delusion that she did no wrong? Better, I bid you study how easily so many professional investors (trained to never invest a dime before doing due-diligence — beginning with Show Me! — were duped.

Cari Kidd's avatar

It’s Oppenheim, not Oppenheimer

Celia Owens's avatar

I have been enjoying your aritcles and films since I discovered them by accident a year or so ago, and this one is no exception. However, I hoped that you might touch on something that I have been thinking about, which is this: How many men in Silicon Valley have done more or less the same thing E. Holmes did, and how many of them were prosecuted? Whether hyper-believing in themselves to the point of self-deception, or deliberately deceiving their investors, or being enculturated by their peers to the point of thinking this is the way they are 'supposed' to do business in a start-up, I find myself doubting she is a rare case. Yet I haven't heard of another.

In the end, in spite of the shred of innocence created in this film (and the lack of substantial reference to the mountain of evidence offered in her conviction), I came away as I went in - trusting in the legal system (not always, but by and large) to enforce some standards against fraud, notwithstanding some people's delusions. If a plea of temporary insanity was ever considered, it might have been declined because of future ambitions.